View Single Post
  #10  
Old June 18th 15, 07:14 PM posted to rec.pets.cats.health+behav
Christina Websell
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 8,983
Default In or Out


"Mark Carroll" wrote in message
...
Mack A. Damia writes:

I think I was beaten down a year or so ago when I said that it was
cruel to let your cat roam outside.


It's definitely one of those questions for which there is a massive
cultural difference between countries. For instance, for the UK,
http://www.yourcat.co.uk/General-cat...door-cats.html
has, "In the USA, most cat welfare people recommend an indoor-only life,
while in the UK many would recommend cats have access to the outdoors."
http://www.cats.org.uk/uploads/docum...tdoor_cats.pdf
says, "Ideally all cats would be allowed access to outdoors to express
their natural behaviour."

Now here is a letter, and an answer from a vet:


I'm guessing an American one?

Statistics vary, but house cats live, on average, nine years longer
than their outdoor counterparts.


Individual circumstances vary greatly though. For instance, do you live
right next to fast roads, or out on a rural farm? Secondly, there's
quality of life: even given a shorter lifespan, are those years much
happier for a cat that may explore and hunt as it pleases?

I don't know if you thought that one American vet's opinion is somehow
going to definitively end the debate, but their analysis seems so
simplistic, and expert advice is so diverse, that I suspect you're just
opening it up again.

-- Mark


I won't do in/out arguments versus USA/UK. I am in the UK and my cat is safe
to go out, but I know it's very different.
The worst thing my cat could encounter is a fox and given that he has all
his claws, the fox might come off second best.