A cat forum. CatBanter

If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Go Back   Home » CatBanter forum » Cat Newsgroups » Cat health & behaviour
Site Map Home Register Authors List Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read Web Partners

A question about feeding canned food...



 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #21  
Old September 10th 04, 04:53 PM
GAUBSTER2
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default

I can't figure out which is worse - a low quality wet food as the primary
food, or a high quality dry...


The low quality wet food is worse. Why would one want to feed high levels of
salt (as one example) in a poor quality wet food?
  #22  
Old September 10th 04, 05:51 PM
kaeli
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default

In article ,
enlightened us with...
I can't figure out which is worse - a low quality wet food as the primary
food, or a high quality dry...


The low quality wet food is worse. Why would one want to feed high levels of
salt (as one example) in a poor quality wet food?


Because I'm worried about them not drinking enough and getting kidney and
bladder problems.
I have lost 3 cats over the course of my life to such problems. I'm afraid of
losing another.
I had one (as a child) who kept getting stones and needing VERY expensive
surgery, so my parents put her down.
Then I lost my Julian and he was only 4. He got a blockage from a bladder
stone and went toxic and by the time I got him to the vet, it was too late.
He was too much of a trouper and I never knew he was sick until I woke up one
morning and he was on his side, mewling in pain, and couldn't walk. He
couldn't pee at all. Total blockage. Poisoned his blood, from what I
understand from what the vet said, and the bladder was nearly ruptured with
some urine leaking into the body cavity.

My parents lost their Tom (I grew up with him, sort of, but he was their cat
and I was out of the house when he passed) at only 13 to renal failure. I
loved him a lot, though, even if he wasn't technically mine. I lived with him
for like 11 years.

So, I'm looking at the pros and cons of quality, wet vs dry, and so on. I
don't think I can bear losing another one young to something I could have
prevented.

If I thought it had nothing to do with their diets, I'd just feed them the
good quality dry and be done with it. It's less expensive (I've spent WAY
more money than usual this month on wet food vs dry and I'm not even getting
the high quality stuff much, since they won't eat it) and they enjoy it more.
I'm just very worried about their health.
2 cans a day shared by 3 cats averages $1 a day right now. When they really
start eating it, it'll be a can each and hopefully better quality stuff in
there, so probably more like $2 a day. That's $60 a month. That's a LOT more
than the $25 a month I spent on two bags of very good (not best; they won't
eat that) quality dry.
So if the good quality dry is just as good or better than the lower quality
wet, I'd be more than happy to let them have it.

--
--
~kaeli~
I love God.
It's His fanclub that I can't stand.
http://www.ipwebdesign.net/wildAtHeart
http://www.ipwebdesign.net/kaelisSpace

  #23  
Old September 10th 04, 05:51 PM
kaeli
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default

In article ,
enlightened us with...
I can't figure out which is worse - a low quality wet food as the primary
food, or a high quality dry...


The low quality wet food is worse. Why would one want to feed high levels of
salt (as one example) in a poor quality wet food?


Because I'm worried about them not drinking enough and getting kidney and
bladder problems.
I have lost 3 cats over the course of my life to such problems. I'm afraid of
losing another.
I had one (as a child) who kept getting stones and needing VERY expensive
surgery, so my parents put her down.
Then I lost my Julian and he was only 4. He got a blockage from a bladder
stone and went toxic and by the time I got him to the vet, it was too late.
He was too much of a trouper and I never knew he was sick until I woke up one
morning and he was on his side, mewling in pain, and couldn't walk. He
couldn't pee at all. Total blockage. Poisoned his blood, from what I
understand from what the vet said, and the bladder was nearly ruptured with
some urine leaking into the body cavity.

My parents lost their Tom (I grew up with him, sort of, but he was their cat
and I was out of the house when he passed) at only 13 to renal failure. I
loved him a lot, though, even if he wasn't technically mine. I lived with him
for like 11 years.

So, I'm looking at the pros and cons of quality, wet vs dry, and so on. I
don't think I can bear losing another one young to something I could have
prevented.

If I thought it had nothing to do with their diets, I'd just feed them the
good quality dry and be done with it. It's less expensive (I've spent WAY
more money than usual this month on wet food vs dry and I'm not even getting
the high quality stuff much, since they won't eat it) and they enjoy it more.
I'm just very worried about their health.
2 cans a day shared by 3 cats averages $1 a day right now. When they really
start eating it, it'll be a can each and hopefully better quality stuff in
there, so probably more like $2 a day. That's $60 a month. That's a LOT more
than the $25 a month I spent on two bags of very good (not best; they won't
eat that) quality dry.
So if the good quality dry is just as good or better than the lower quality
wet, I'd be more than happy to let them have it.

--
--
~kaeli~
I love God.
It's His fanclub that I can't stand.
http://www.ipwebdesign.net/wildAtHeart
http://www.ipwebdesign.net/kaelisSpace

  #24  
Old September 11th 04, 12:39 AM
Steve G
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default

kaeli wrote in message . ..
(...)
I'm just very worried about their health.
2 cans a day shared by 3 cats averages $1 a day right now. When they really
start eating it, it'll be a can each and hopefully better quality stuff in
there, so probably more like $2 a day. That's $60 a month.


Wow, unless you are buying small cans, your cats eat a lot! Mine are
on one-quarter of a large can each per day, and .125-.33 of a cup of
dry each per day. That's around 75c/day (37c/cat), $22/month. I might
even need to reduce their intake slightly to stop one of 'em from
becoming a furry lardarse.

(...)
So if the good quality dry is just as good or better than the lower quality
wet, I'd be more than happy to let them have it.


I guess the problem is that if don't know whether your cats are
especially susceptible to urinary nastyness, then you don't know
whether it's best to err on the side of water intake (****ty wet food)
versus generally better nutritional profile (quality dry).

It might be possible to increase a cat's water intake by altering the
temperature or presentation method of their water - don't know if
anyone has actually researched this though. (I keep meaning to do an
n=2 experiment myself, comparing the water intake when a fountain is
available versus when a bowl is the weapon of choice. Dunno if I'll
ever do this though).

Uselessly and parathetically,
Steve.
  #25  
Old September 11th 04, 12:39 AM
Steve G
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default

kaeli wrote in message . ..
(...)
I'm just very worried about their health.
2 cans a day shared by 3 cats averages $1 a day right now. When they really
start eating it, it'll be a can each and hopefully better quality stuff in
there, so probably more like $2 a day. That's $60 a month.


Wow, unless you are buying small cans, your cats eat a lot! Mine are
on one-quarter of a large can each per day, and .125-.33 of a cup of
dry each per day. That's around 75c/day (37c/cat), $22/month. I might
even need to reduce their intake slightly to stop one of 'em from
becoming a furry lardarse.

(...)
So if the good quality dry is just as good or better than the lower quality
wet, I'd be more than happy to let them have it.


I guess the problem is that if don't know whether your cats are
especially susceptible to urinary nastyness, then you don't know
whether it's best to err on the side of water intake (****ty wet food)
versus generally better nutritional profile (quality dry).

It might be possible to increase a cat's water intake by altering the
temperature or presentation method of their water - don't know if
anyone has actually researched this though. (I keep meaning to do an
n=2 experiment myself, comparing the water intake when a fountain is
available versus when a bowl is the weapon of choice. Dunno if I'll
ever do this though).

Uselessly and parathetically,
Steve.
  #28  
Old September 13th 04, 02:44 PM
kaeli
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default

In article ,
enlightened us with...
kaeli wrote in message . ..
(...)
I'm just very worried about their health.
2 cans a day shared by 3 cats averages $1 a day right now. When they really
start eating it, it'll be a can each and hopefully better quality stuff in
there, so probably more like $2 a day. That's $60 a month.


Wow, unless you are buying small cans, your cats eat a lot!


Oh, they don't eat it all. I just don't like to store wet food in the fridge
and then have to heat it. So they share one in the morning and one in the
evening, but they rarely finish it all. So, they each get about a half a can
a day plus a little dry.
The "recommended serving" on the cans says a can per day per 8 pound cat.
The cans are, IIRC, somewhere around 5 oz.
The cans range from 40 cents to $1 each, depending on what kind I buy.

I'm so used to free-feeding dry, I have no clue how much wet to give them.

(...)
So if the good quality dry is just as good or better than the lower quality
wet, I'd be more than happy to let them have it.


I guess the problem is that if don't know whether your cats are
especially susceptible to urinary nastyness, then you don't know
whether it's best to err on the side of water intake (****ty wet food)
versus generally better nutritional profile (quality dry).


I know.
I worry most about Rowan and Jeffrey. Rowan, because she's always been a
little sickly and she gets dehydrated very quickly and Jeffrey b/c he's a
boy. Isis always seems well-hydrated.
They all drink ample water.

I think what I'm going to do is give them whatever wet they like the most in
the morning and late afternoon and leave them a half-cup of their higher-
quality dry to share overnight.


--
--
~kaeli~
Quantum Express: When you absolutely, positively, don't
know where it's going or when it needs to be there.
http://www.ipwebdesign.net/wildAtHeart
http://www.ipwebdesign.net/kaelisSpace

  #29  
Old September 13th 04, 02:44 PM
kaeli
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default

In article ,
enlightened us with...
kaeli wrote in message . ..
(...)
I'm just very worried about their health.
2 cans a day shared by 3 cats averages $1 a day right now. When they really
start eating it, it'll be a can each and hopefully better quality stuff in
there, so probably more like $2 a day. That's $60 a month.


Wow, unless you are buying small cans, your cats eat a lot!


Oh, they don't eat it all. I just don't like to store wet food in the fridge
and then have to heat it. So they share one in the morning and one in the
evening, but they rarely finish it all. So, they each get about a half a can
a day plus a little dry.
The "recommended serving" on the cans says a can per day per 8 pound cat.
The cans are, IIRC, somewhere around 5 oz.
The cans range from 40 cents to $1 each, depending on what kind I buy.

I'm so used to free-feeding dry, I have no clue how much wet to give them.

(...)
So if the good quality dry is just as good or better than the lower quality
wet, I'd be more than happy to let them have it.


I guess the problem is that if don't know whether your cats are
especially susceptible to urinary nastyness, then you don't know
whether it's best to err on the side of water intake (****ty wet food)
versus generally better nutritional profile (quality dry).


I know.
I worry most about Rowan and Jeffrey. Rowan, because she's always been a
little sickly and she gets dehydrated very quickly and Jeffrey b/c he's a
boy. Isis always seems well-hydrated.
They all drink ample water.

I think what I'm going to do is give them whatever wet they like the most in
the morning and late afternoon and leave them a half-cup of their higher-
quality dry to share overnight.


--
--
~kaeli~
Quantum Express: When you absolutely, positively, don't
know where it's going or when it needs to be there.
http://www.ipwebdesign.net/wildAtHeart
http://www.ipwebdesign.net/kaelisSpace

 




Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Can Cats Eat Dog Food? JHBennett Cat anecdotes 31 January 29th 05 10:42 AM
What is REALLY in your pet's food? catsdogs Cat health & behaviour 2 May 12th 04 05:57 AM
feed Nutro? Tamara Cat health & behaviour 90 November 19th 03 01:57 AM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:54 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 CatBanter.
The comments are property of their posters.